For several years I have been most fascinated with something called a hummingbird moth. I fell in love instantly the first time I saw one buzzing through the bee balm at a perennial nursery. I have been trying for years to attract one of these beneficial pollinators by purchasing certain things for our flowerbeds.
No matter what I plant, I still have not had the joy of watching a fuzzy, thick-bodied hummingbird moth hover over a flower to drink in my own yard. This year I was beginning to think about researching ways to bring the eggs or larvae in from a supplier.
That was all before gardening season began in earnest.
Last week, as I watered the garden first thing in the morning, I came upon a pepper plant that had been practically eaten down to a stalk. Underneath the plant was a pile of “frass,” which is the waste that a caterpillar leaves behind after a meal. I looked at all the neighboring plants and sure enough, there was a big, fat tomato hornworm. All of my conditioning told me to squish it or feed it to the chickens. I chose the latter and was walking it across the yard when something made me pause and wonder what it would become if I didn’t let it get eaten.
Tomato Hornworm: Beneficial Pollinators?
There are two types of hornworm that feed on the tomato family – the tobacco hornworm (Manduca sexta) and the tomato hornworm (Manduca quinquemaculata). They are part of the family of moths called sphinx moths, so named for the way they stand up when disturbed. They all have a horn on their tail, fleshy bodies, and are brown or green in color as caterpillars. The tobacco hornworm has diagonal white lines along its side and the tomato hornworm has white v’s.
As I read on about them, I found that the sphinx moths are often called hummingbird moths. There is actually a hummingbird moth in the family (Hymaris thysbe), so the common name for the class of moths is a bit of a misnomer. Nonetheless, many of the sphinx moths hover and drink nectar from their proboscis.
The very moth with which I was fascinated was not present in my garden because I had been killing all of its caterpillars!
I changed course with my wiggly prize. There are no more juicy hornworm snacks for the chickens on our farm. Instead, I called the kids out and we put it in a large jar. Now, of course, we can’t allow the hornworm to take over the tomato row or we won’t have any tomatoes. They can strip a plant in no time, so we had to come up with a few new strategies to coexist.
How I Deal With the Tomato Hornworm
This year I am placing any caterpillars we find in jars and letting the kids take care of them until they emerge as moths. It is best to look for them at night with a flashlight, or first thing in the morning on the undersides of leaves.
The jar we are using has some soil in the bottom of it. The caterpillar will need to burrow its cocoon into this dirt when it is ready to change over to a moth. We are leaving the top open or covering it with a screen. While the caterpillar needs to eat, we can impact our tomatoes less by choosing a leaf here and there throughout the row. Anything in the solanaceae family can be used. The moth should take about two weeks to emerge during the summer months.
Next year, we will be planting a sacrificial area of peppers and tomatoes. Every year we grow more seedlings of both of these than we need. It doesn’t take much to set up a separate little row or bed of them. As we find caterpillars on our garden tomatoes, we’ll pick them off and carry them to the “moth bed.” They’ll have everything they need there and won’t require any interference from us.
By next year, I should be able to sit on my deck and watch the sphinx moths feed.
Be careful what you squish in your garden. We should all take the time to understand the place each pest holds in a healthy ecosystem. We’ve been taught that it’s a battle between good and evil out there. The truth is much less black and white.