10 Candy Alternatives for a Healthier Halloween

This post may contain affiliate links.

Healthy Halloween Treats

For the past few years we have lived on a busy street without a sidewalk, so we never had to think much about trick-or-treaters. This year, we find ourselves in the opposite situation. We have moved to a quiet neighborhood where trick-or-treaters will be plentiful!

I like to get a head start on holidays, so I’m already looking at candy. Those bags of candy are EXPENSIVE! They are also full of sugar, preservatives, high fructose corn syrup, and worse.

Needless to say, I had to look into healthy Halloween treats as a better alternative. I think it will be nice to have something different, along with some non-candy alternatives that will work for children with food sensitives or allergies.

Below are ten healthy Halloween treats I found. Some are more affordable than others, so I plan to get a mix of the group. I hope you find something that will work for your Halloween treat basket!

Healthy Halloween Treats


Sticker Sheets

These sheets are way better than just getting ONE sticker. At $11.99 for 60 sheets, you can give each sheet to a child and it will cost you under $0.20 for each child! That’s a great way to replace candy. Plus, the wide assortment means there will be something for everyone. There’s a reason why doctor’s offices still pass out stickers to kids – it is sure to bring a smile! (Get them here.)

Organic Natural Lollipops

While these are technically still candy, they are naturally flavored with fruit juice, allergen free, AND USDA Organic, vegan, gluten free, Non-GMO Project Verified, kosher pareve. This large container has 125 lollipops for $16.35. That’s only $0.13 per pop. Plus, you sure won’t run out! We keep these lollipops on hand for potty training, positive reinforcement, or just a little treat. They taste amazing! (Get them here.)

Natural Lip Balm

Now this option is a little more pricey. At $18.97 for 24 tubes, it will cost you $0.80 each. BUT if you only expect a few trick-or-treaters or if you add them to a basket of various goodies, they would make a good option. I normally am hesitant to DIY for Halloween because you may not know everyone coming to your door and it’s good to be careful these days. I wouldn’t let my own children eat or use homemade goodies unless I personally knew the person who made them. (Get a box of natural lip balms here.)

Natural Gummy Snacks

These snacks are gluten-free and vegan, plus contain no artificial flavors, synthetic colors, preservatives, or high-fructose corn syrup. For almost $15 you get 24 packs, so about $0.65 each. There was also a $3.00 coupon on Amazon as I was writing this post, so that would make them even less! (Get them here.)

Non-toxic temporary tattoos

Kids love temporary tattoos and they are CHEAP! You’ll want to be careful though and choose a non-toxic product as a lot of these come from overseas. You can get Halloween inspired tattoos, or choose another variety like animals, Disney, flowers, or vehicles. (Get them here.)

Glow Bracelets

Glow bracelets are a great option for Halloween! They light up, are easy to put on, and come in a variety of colors. This pack contains 110 glow bracelets for just $7.99. They are non-toxic, non-heat generating, non-flammable, non-radioactive and come in five fun colors. (Get them here.)


While I’m not the biggest playdough fan, this is a good option for littler trick-or-treaters. Normally I make homemade playdough, but these individual playdough containers are affordable and fun. (Get them here.)

Emoji Stress balls

Anything with emojis will be appealing to older trick-or-treaters! I found some cute stress balls that are non-toxic and BPA free. (Get them here.)

Halloween inspired pencils

These No.2 pencils are perfect for school-aged children. They are non-toxic and have several different designs. (Get them here.)

Organic Juice boxes

Running around all night can make kids thirsty! These organic juice boxes will be something different and useful. Plus, they are smaller than some of the other brands, which is good for your wallet and easier for kids to carry around. (Get them here.)

What healthy Halloween treats are you excited to hand out this year?


About Katie Vance

Katie is a wife, mother, aromatherapist, and lover of all things DIY. She offers consultations and gives simple aromatherapy advice at Katie Vance, Aromatherapy Simplified. You can also find Katie on Facebook.

PAID ENDORSEMENT DISCLOSURE: In order for us to support our website activities, we may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for our endorsement, recommendation, testimonial and/or link to any products or services from this website.

DISCLAIMER: Information on DIY Natural™ is not reviewed or endorsed by the FDA and is NOT intended to be substituted for the advice of your health care professional. If you rely solely upon this advice you do so at your own risk. Read full Disclaimer & Disclosure statements here.


  1. Nana says

    For years and years we have given out money. If we don’t have enough change around the house, I stop by the bank and get rolls of change. I found it is much cheaper to give money than buy the candy and take the chance that we will run out. The kids love it. Sometimes I let them reach into the bowl and get a big handful and other times, I’ll give them a big handful. Many of them walk away yelling, “that lady’s giving out money!”

  2. Christy says

    I have used Halloween pencils, glow bracelets and stickers for years and kids LOVE them. They never ask where the candy is.

  3. Kelly Mahan says

    All of these treats sound super cool! I’m definitely making some for my halloween party. Thank you for sharing!